14.35 Cheltenham (updated: 07.14)
There is little doubt that TIDAL BAY is a quirky horse, and he seems to have developed something of a ‘comedy’ reputation, often described as being an ‘unpredictable’ character with ‘a mind of his own’. However, whilst recognising that he has a pretty unique run-style (regularly gets behind before storming home with his customary high head-carriage), I think his reputation of being unpredictable is largely unjustified, and his quirkiness seems to have overshadowed the fact that he remains a top-class performer when he gets his conditions.
Tidal Bay was clearly effective at shorter trips/on quicker ground as a younger horse, but in recent years (as he has increasingly developed the tendency to get behind in his races) his profile/form suggests he likely needs a trip of 3m+ with a decent cut in the ground (may not want it heavy) in order to to run to a high level. Indeed, despite his reputation of being unpredictable, his career form at trips of 3m+ when racing on ‘good-soft’ or ‘soft’ ground reads: 2-1-2-2-3, achieving RPRs of 169, 164, 170, 166 and 160. It also makes intuitive sense that a horse who has become lazier/trickier with age, and who can get some way behind his rivals, might need a longer trip/softer ground to help ‘pull’ him into a race. Furthermore, Tidal Bay seems to really like Cheltenham, where the testing nature of the track and uphill finish seems to suit his strong-finishing style (his poorer efforts here seemingly down to inappropriate trips/ground).
I think it’s therefore quite easy to argue that Tidal Bay is nothing like as unpredictable as if often claimed. When getting his conditions he seems to be at least a solid 160-165 performer, and there is a fair chance champion trainer Paul Nicholls can extract some more improvement from him. He has had a breathing operation since joining his current yard (was reported to have made a noise on the gallops soon after arriving), and made a very pleasing debut for the stable (reported to be in need of the run) when running a good third from a mark of 160 over hurdles at Cheltenham on New Years Day.
Another positive is the possibility of a strong pace. Tidal Bay’s style means that he naturally struggles to come from behind off a slow/accelerating gallop, but there are plenty of potential front-runners (6 of the 9 runners look to be contenders to lead) in here, and it is hoped that between them they can set up a ‘fast-fast-slow’ style race, where Tidal Bay can utilise his strong finish to stay on past tiring rivals late on.
If I could hand-pick optimum conditions for Tidal Bay, then 3m1f110y on good-soft at Cheltenham would likely be close to the mark, so there looks to be a good chance he can show something like his best form here. Not only does Tidal Bay look to have near-perfect conditions, but I also think many of those at the top of the market look vulnerable/underpriced. Captain Chris is a classy sort but, despite managing a respectable sounding 3rd, he didn’t jump, travel or stay on in the King George. He arguably wasn’t at his best there, and better can be expected in time, but this will likely be a pretty severe stamina test and his profile suggests he will be better on good spring ground. Time For Rupert, Diamond Harry and Midnight Chase are shorter in the market than the selection, and are all capable performers on their day, but in my view it’s entirely possible that Tidal Bay can run to a mid-160s+ level here, and if he does that then his rivals face no easy task in conceding 5-6lbs to him.
Many will likely scoff at this suggestion, but I believe Tidal Bay should be challenging for favouritism today, and with a decent round of jumping I’d expect him to be hard to beat. Diamond Harry, who went well for a long way in the Betfair Chase on his return, is feared most.
RESULT: PLACED (2nd)
16.15 Cheltenham (updated: 09.48)
ART PROFESSOR makes a fair bit of appeal in the closing 2m1f handicap hurdle at Cheltenham. He won this race last year, and it may initially seem that he needs to improve a fair bit to follow up that narrow victory from a 9lb higher mark. However, that form has worked out particularly well – the 2nd, 3rd and 4th are now respectively rated 21lbs, 8lbs and 14lbs higher than the ratings they ran off that day – and he may not need to improve too much to go close again. Furthermore, he shaped well to be third on his seasonal reappearance at Kempton last month, and his yard are in much better form now (Venetia Williams’ strike-rate was just 7% in December, compared to 19% January to date). At 8/1 he looks decent value against 9/4 favourite Hinterland , who is nevertheless feared. Dare Me and First In The Queue are also respected, with the latter looking worthy of a small saver at 14/1+ too.
RESULT: PLACED (2nd)